Skip to content
THE ACQUISITION OFFICELONDON | CHESHIRE | MANCHESTER
← All InsightsProperty Library →

Buying & Negotiation

An asking price is a proposition. How should you test it?

An asking price opens a conversation. It does not settle what a home is worth. A useful appraisal looks at the property, the evidence and your own alternatives together before you decide what to offer.

The Acquisition Office 4 min read

Red-brick residential buildings with arched entrances and iron railings

The perspective

Negotiate from a well reasoned position, not a percentage off the headline figure. The price and terms should reflect the evidence, the risks and what matters to you.

Which prices are evidence, and which are expectations?

Start by separating completed sales from asking prices, reductions and informal talk of offers. Land Registry sold prices are a useful starting point, although records appear some time after a sale and say little about the home itself. A recently published entry may reflect a price agreed months earlier.

For each comparable sale, note the date, location, tenure and what you can reliably learn about the accommodation and condition, and be honest about the gaps. If evidence is thin, widen the comparison carefully and be clear about why another street or building is relevant, rather than treating a weak comparison as certain.

What makes a nearby sale genuinely comparable?

Within a single building, floor level, lift access, outlook, outside space, remaining lease length and refurbishment can make flats very different. For houses, the garden, parking, layout, position on the street and upkeep all play a part. Comparing floor areas helps, but it cannot account for these differences on its own.

Check that floor areas have been measured in the same way, and ask whether attractive space is genuinely useful to you. There is no need to invent a precise adjustment for every difference. Our residential sales and acquisition experience informs our view on value, but that is not a formal valuation, which should be commissioned separately where needed.

Questions to take forward

  • Which completed sales have comparable tenure and usable accommodation?
  • What differences weaken each comparison?
  • What is known about condition and transaction timing?
  • Where does the evidence remain uncertain?

What will the home require after purchase?

Look at the price alongside any expected works, running costs and buying costs. A cheaper flat in a building facing major works may not cost less overall. A finished house may also suit a fixed moving date better than a less expensive one needing disruptive refurbishment.

Build the budget from survey findings, legal enquiries and independent estimates, and treat early allowances for works as rough figures. Tax and mortgage questions belong with your qualified advisers. Subtracting a guessed refurbishment cost from the asking price does not produce a reliable valuation.

Which terms matter to the seller and to you?

Ask the selling agent about the seller’s timing, chain, what is included and how competing offers will be handled. A seller may value certainty or flexibility, but that should come from real conversation rather than guesses about their personal circumstances.

Be accurate about your own position, including any sale you depend on, your lender’s requirements or funds held overseas. An offer that is clear about price, funding, proposed dates and outstanding checks is often taken more seriously than a higher figure resting on an unrealistic timetable.

How do you set an opening position and a limit?

Decide on your preferred offer, the reasoning behind it and the most you would be comfortable paying on what you know so far, together with the terms that matter and the checks still needed. Keep that limit private. It is there to guide your decisions, not to be announced as a tactic.

Explain your offer clearly without a long list of criticisms. If the seller says no, find out why and compare any revised position with your alternatives. There is no standard opening discount. Being prepared to walk away only works if you genuinely mean it.

When is a revised offer justified?

A significant survey or legal finding may change the risk, the budget or whether the home still suits you. Ask the relevant professional what has changed, what further checks are needed and whether the remedy can be reliably costed. Then explain the consequences to the seller clearly, rather than using every minor point as leverage.

In a typical purchase in England and Wales, everything before exchange remains subject to contract, although other ways of selling and signed agreements can differ. Your solicitor advises on commitments and handles the conveyancing. A successful negotiation is a purchase you understand on terms you are happy with, not a promised saving against the first figure.

Questions to take forward

  • What new evidence would change my offer or decision?
  • Are funding, timing and included items accurately recorded?
  • Has my solicitor reviewed any proposed commitment?
  • Would I still choose this home at the total anticipated cost?

Further reference

Put the reading in context

General educational information, not a substitute for individual legal, tax, mortgage or surveying advice. Consult appropriately qualified independent advisers about your property and circumstances.

Your next acquisition

Bring the price into perspective.

If you have found a home, talk to us about the asking price, the evidence and your own circumstances before deciding how to negotiate.